Feedback: Day 12 of Four Weeks to Rubber Soul

What if “Drive My Car” had stayed “Golden Rings?” That may be one of the great what if questions in Beatles lyrical history. Paul McCartney came into the writing process with the beginnings of a song and an idea involving golden rings, but the idea was not quite working. Rather than protecting the first version simply because it was his, Paul kept working with John Lennon until they found a new direction. Eventually, “Drive My Car” emerged.

That story says a lot about feedback because feedback is necessary for any creative pursuit. We need thoughts, responses, questions, and ideas from other people because we cannot always see everything in our own work. We all have blind spots. Sometimes another person helps us recognize something that needs attention. Other times, feedback gives us validation that something is working and encourages us to keep moving forward.

Receiving feedback requires openness, and it also requires trust. We need people around us who understand what we are trying to accomplish and care enough to help us grow. The best feedback does not come from someone simply looking for flaws. It comes from trusted bandmates who are willing to listen, respond, challenge, encourage, and help us hear something we may be missing.

Being open to feedback does not mean we have to accept every suggestion. Feedback requires reflection and discernment because someone can offer a thoughtful idea that still may not belong in your work. Another person might notice something you initially resist, only to realize later that they were hearing something important. Creative growth requires enough confidence to maintain your own voice and enough humility to consider another perspective.

The goal of feedback is not obedience. The goal is growth, and that idea becomes even more meaningful when we look beyond “Drive My Car” and consider Rubber Soul as a whole. The album represents a moment when The Beatles knew they had to continue growing. They had already achieved extraordinary success, yet repeating what had worked before was not enough. Their songwriting was becoming more reflective, their musical palette was expanding, and new influences were finding their way into the room.

Rubber Soul is evidence of creative people taking bold initial steps toward innovation. The Beatles listened to one another, brought different ideas into the room, experimented with sounds and instruments, and allowed songs to change. They responded to new influences and trusted their evolving instincts. They did not have every future album mapped out. They simply understood that growth required movement.

That is one reason Rubber Soul continues to inspire me during this month of creativity. It offers more than a collection of incredible songs because it provides a template for creative growth.Rubber Soul reminds us to begin the work, listen to our creative muse, collaborate with kindred spirits, and experiment our expression. Like The Beatles, we welcome trusted feedback, reflect on what we hear, and keep what helps the work become stronger.

Every creative person needs people who can help them see and hear what they may be missing. The challenge is learning how to receive that perspective without surrendering your own voice. Listen with openness, give yourself time to reflect, and discern what will help the work grow. Sometimes the next creative breakthrough may begin with the willingness to hear something differently.

Check out today’s reel on Feedback:

2 thoughts on “Feedback: Day 12 of Four Weeks to Rubber Soul”

  1. Sean……I have been remiss in providing you appropriate feedback on your Rubber Soul reflections. Each and every one has been an enjoyable read and the content of each entry worthy of discussion and consideration. What fantastic discussions could come out of specific topics you have covered – dividing the faculty up in small groups, giving each group an entry, let them discuss the implications for their classroom, school, collaborations with other staff members, etc. Then, at an appropriate time, every group provide a summary of their ideas to the group. I know there are a host of other activities that could be done, but I’ve only had one cup of coffee at this point! I could imagine an entire “workshop” based on the lessons learned from the Rubber Soul LP. You are a very discerning writer, and I appreciate and look forward to all of your keen observations. Just wish we were closer as it would be great fun to share “war stories,” ideas, and possibilities to use “in the trenches.” Continue to be inspired. Gene

    Like

    • Gene, thanks so much for your generous words and insights! I appreciate you taking the time to read and share. It is hard to know what lands when I send this content into the world. I appreciate your connection to the schoolhouse in your comments. It’s good to be in the band with you!

      Like

Leave a comment