When Bandmates Fade Away

There was a time when my Professional Learning Network felt like one of the most wonderful bands I had ever joined. We were educators from different schools, districts, and backgrounds who found common ground through our shared passion for learning and leadership. We connected through Twitter chats, EdCamps, conferences, and conversations that extended beyond our professional lives. Somewhere along the way, those connections became friendships, and some became an important part of my story.

I remember the excitement of those early years and the joy of finding people who understood my work, challenged my thinking, and celebrated alongside me. We exchanged ideas, encouraged one another, and shared plenty of laughter. For someone navigating the complexities and occasional loneliness of school leadership, those relationships provided a genuine sense of belonging. Looking back, I realize that the greatest gift of my PLN was never the professional learning itself. It was the people who made me feel seen, valued, and connected.

When the Music Changes

Relationships evolve as life moves forward. People change jobs, pursue new opportunities, develop different interests, and find themselves navigating unfamiliar seasons. Conversations that once happened regularly become occasional exchanges. Eventually, some connections grow quiet, and friendships that once seemed inseparable become memories of another time.

There are people with whom I once shared meaningful conversations, laughter, professional dreams, and personal struggles who are no longer part of my everyday life. Some relationships simply faded with time. Others were wonderful friendships that gradually changed as we grew apart and discovered that the common ground we once shared had shifted. There was no disagreement or defining moment. Life simply carried us in different directions.

Some of that distance has also emerged from differences in our values and perspectives on education. I have watched former connections become increasingly drawn toward the culture of educelebrity, where certain personalities seem to command extraordinary attention and influence. I have struggled with aspects of that culture, particularly when I perceive educators’ enthusiasm, loyalty, and desire for belonging being leveraged for personal visibility or professional gain. I have never been comfortable with the idea that educational leadership should revolve around personalities rather than people and purpose.

It has been disappointing to see relationships change as those differences became more apparent. I do not expect everyone to share my perspective, nor do I question the sincerity of every educator who finds inspiration in those spaces. Still, I have become more intentional about the people and communities with whom I align myself. I want to be part of conversations where collaboration matters more than celebrity, where ideas are valued beyond the individuals promoting them, and where educators are treated as colleagues rather than audiences.

When Belonging Becomes Exclusion

There is another experience that has stayed with me, and it has been more difficult to reconcile. I was once part of a PLN that initially represented everything I loved about professional collaboration. There was genuine excitement around exchanging ideas, supporting one another, and creating opportunities for educators to learn together. Over time, however, I began to sense a shift in the culture of that community.

What had once felt open and collaborative gradually became more exclusive. A smaller circle seemed to emerge, and the spirit of shared learning began to feel overshadowed by an increasingly insular social dynamic. I found myself feeling alienated from a community where I had once experienced genuine belonging. It was especially disheartening to watch adults, particularly educators who championed inclusion and relationships, begin to operate in ways that reminded me of the very cliques we work so hard to discourage among students.

That experience hurt because I believed deeply in what the community originally represented. I had invested my time, energy, and enthusiasm in those relationships. I also recognize that others may have experienced that community differently. My reflections are shaped by my own experiences rather than any claim to understand everyone’s intentions. Still, the experience reminded me that belonging must be more than something we celebrate in professional conversations. It must be something we practice through our actions.

Celebrating Monday Alone

Perhaps one of the most difficult realizations in reflecting on my PLN is recognizing how much of myself I invested in an online community, sometimes at the expense of the relationships right in front of me.

There were seasons when I prioritized my PLN over friends, colleagues, and even family members who were physically present in my life. I devoted countless hours to online conversations, professional collaborations, and building connections with educators across the country and around the world. I was so invested in nurturing those relationships that I sometimes failed to give the same attention and energy to the people who shared my everyday life.

That realization has been humbling because those relationships suffered. There were moments when I was more engaged with a conversation happening on my phone than with the people sitting beside me. I was working so hard to create a sense of community beyond my immediate surroundings that I sometimes overlooked the community already within my reach.

I think about #CelebrateMonday, a movement I created to encourage educators to begin each week with positivity, gratitude, and a celebration of the meaningful work happening in schools. Watching that hashtag become a trending topic and seeing schools embrace the spirit of celebration brought me tremendous joy. It was gratifying to know that an idea rooted in optimism could encourage so many educators and school communities.

Yet there was an irony in that experience that I did not fully recognize at the time. While educators and schools were celebrating Monday through a movement I had helped create, I often found myself celebrating Monday alone. I was encouraging connection and belonging on a broad scale while sometimes struggling to experience those same things in my immediate surroundings.

I do not regret creating #CelebrateMonday or the relationships that grew from it. I remain proud of the positive impact it had on educators and schools. What I regret is not always recognizing that the people closest to me deserved the same presence, encouragement, and intentionality that I so willingly offered to a community online.

Finding My Way Back

These experiences have encouraged me to examine my own responsibility for sustaining relationships. Have I reached out enough? Have I checked on the people who once checked on me? Have I allowed disappointment, exhaustion, or the demands of leadership to create distance where there was once genuine friendship? I know there have been times when I could have done better.

Leadership can consume an extraordinary amount of emotional energy, and personal struggles have occasionally made withdrawing easier than explaining what I was experiencing. I also recognize that others may have been navigating their own challenges. A friendship that grows quiet has not necessarily lost its meaning. Sometimes, people are simply trying to find their way through life, and that realization invites me to extend grace rather than assume indifference.

Music has always helped me understand experiences that are difficult to explain. I think about the bands whose music has accompanied me throughout my life. Some remain together for decades, while others create something extraordinary before their members pursue different paths. The music they made together does not become less meaningful simply because the band no longer exists in its original form.

Perhaps friendships work in much the same way. I can remember those early PLN experiences with gratitude rather than regret. The conversations at EdCamps, the friendships formed through social media, and the encouragement offered during professional transitions all contributed to the person I am today. Those experiences mattered, and the people who shared them with me still matter, even when our lives have moved in different directions.

What has changed is my understanding of where I need to invest my time and emotional energy. I am learning to lean more deeply into my own humanity and become more intentional about being present for the people I care about in real time. I want to be more available for conversations that happen across a table rather than through a screen. I want to listen more carefully, reach out more consistently, and appreciate the relationships that exist beyond professional recognition or shared interests.

I still believe in the power of a Professional Learning Network and the possibilities that emerge when people connect through shared passions. I also believe that belonging must begin with how we treat the people closest to us. The relationships that sustain us are not always the ones that generate the most visibility or professional opportunities. Sometimes, they are the quiet friendships and everyday connections that remind us who we are when the professional noise fades.

When I think about my PLN today, I still hear the echoes of those wonderful early conversations. Some bandmates are still playing alongside me, while others have found different rhythms. A few connections ended in ways I never anticipated, while others simply faded as our lives changed. I can acknowledge the disappointment of some experiences without allowing them to diminish the joy of others.

I am grateful for the music we made together, and I wish those former bandmates well. I am also learning that I do not need to keep searching for a place in every band or a seat at every table. There is meaningful work to do and love to share with the people who are already part of my life.

I spent years trying to bring people together across the world. Now I am learning that some of the most meaningful connections begin by being fully present with the people right beside me.

Leave a Reply